Sromkey: Created page with "Main Page > Projects > Vancouver Digital Archives > System Testing > Test File Results == DROID, JHOVE, NLNZ Metadata Extractor == The purpose of these thr..."

2015-07-03T19:55:52Z

Created page with "Main Page > Projects > Vancouver Digital Archives > System Testing > Test File Results == DROID, JHOVE, NLNZ Metadata Extractor == The purpose of these thr..."

New page

[[Main Page]] > [[Projects]] > [[Vancouver Digital Archives]] > [[System Testing]] > Test File Results

== DROID, JHOVE, NLNZ Metadata Extractor ==

The purpose of these three tools is to validate formats and extract technical metadata. For more information see Technology/Tools Evaluation > [[DROID, JHOVE, NLNZ Metadata Extractor]]

{| border="1" cellpadding="20" cellspacing="0"
!File
!Description
!DROID
!NLNZ
!JHOVE
!Comments
|-
|0239.mpg
|MPEG-2 video file
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: 0239.mpg]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: 0239.mpg]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: 0239.mpg]]
|
|-
|2001-04-LegendsPBP_512kb.mp4
|MPEG-4 video file
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: 2001-04-LegendsPBP_512kb.mp4|DROID: 2001-04-LegendsPBP
_512kb.mp4]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: 2001-04-LegendsPBP_512kb.mp4]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: 2001-04-LegendsPBP_512kb.mp4]]
|
|-
|A08917.TIF
|TIFF image file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: A08917.TIF]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[NLNZ: A08917.TIF]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[JHOVE: A08917.TIF]]
|
*DROID suggested 4 possible versions (3.0 to 6.0)
|-
|accelerando.com
|Website consisting of html, xhtml, css, jpg, gif and png files
|
*Identified formats? '''YES'''
*Identified versions? '''PARTIALLY'''
*[[DROID: accelerando.com]]
|
*Identified formats? '''PARTIALLY'''
*Identified versions? '''PARTIALLY'''
*[[NLNZ: accelerando.com]]
|
*Identified formats? '''PARTIALLY'''
*Identified versions? '''PARTIALLY'''
*[[JHOVE: accelerando.com]]
|
*DROID correctly identified all but css file which it identified tentatively as either cascading style sheet or Stats+ Data File; identified versions of all other files
*NLNZ did not identify css and identified XHTML file as HTML; identified all other formats; identified versions of html and gif files, not of jpg files
*JHOVE identified css as ASCII and did not identify png; identified all other formats and versions
|-
|artefactual.com.zip
|Zip archive containing html, css, jpg, gif and png files
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: artefactual.com.zip]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: artefactual.com.zip]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: artefactual.com.zip]]
|
*DROID identified as ZIP format but did not process individual zipped files
*NLNZ identified as mimetype "application/zip" but did not process individual zipped files, even when the zip archive was processed as a single complex object
|-
|Basic search.odt
|OpenOffice.org Writer file with inserted png file.
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: Basic search.odt]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[NLNZ: Basic search.odt]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: Basic search.odt]]
|
*DROID incorrectly identified as zip file and warned of "possible file extension mismatch"; did not process inserted png
*NLNZ correctly identified format and versions but did not process inserted png
|-
|ct000654.jp2
|JPEG2000 image file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[DROID: ct00654.jp2]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[NLNZ: ct000654.jp2]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[JHOVE: ct000654.jp2]]
|
*DROID correctly identified but identification was "tentative"
|-
|DadClip_64kb.mp3
|MPEG-1 Audio Layer-3 file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[DROID: DadClip_64kb.mp3]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[NLNZ: DadClip_64kb.mp3]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: DadClip_64kb.mp3]]
|
*DROID correctly identified but identification was "tentative"
|-
|-
|DemoANSI.txt
|US_ASCII text file
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: DemoANSI.txt]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: DemoANSI.txt]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[JHOVE: DemoANSI.txt]]
|
*DROID suggested 9 possible formats: Tab-Delimited Text File, Macintosh Text File, MS-DOS Text File, Unicode Text File, Fixed Width Values Text File, Plain Text File, MS-DOS Text File with line breaks, and IBM DisplayWrite Document
*NLNZ identified as plain text but did not identify encoding
|-
|DemoUTF-8.txt
|Unicode text file
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: DemoUTF-8.txt]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: DemoUTF-8.txt]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[JHOVE: DemoUTF-8.txt]]
|
*DROID suggested 9 possible formats: Tab-Delimited Text File, Macintosh Text File, MS-DOS Text File, Unicode Text File, Fixed Width Values Text File, Plain Text File, MS-DOS Text File with line breaks, and IBM DisplayWrite Document
*NLNZ identified as plain text but did not identify encoding
|-
|Free_to_use_10_sec.aif
|AIF audio file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[DROID: Free_to_use_10_sec.aif]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[NLNZ: Free_to_use_10_sec.aif]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[JHOVE: Free_to_use_10_sec.aif]]
|
*DROID correctly identified but identification was "tentative"
|-
|Holdings.png
|PNG image file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[DROID: Holdings.png]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: Holdings.png]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: Holdings.png]]
|
*NLNZ identified mimetype as image/png but format field was empty
|-
|Ica-atom-technical-architecture-2008-06.gif
|GIF image file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[DROID: Ica-atom-technical-architecture-2008-06.gif]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[NLNZ: Ica-atom-technical-architecture-2008-06.gif|NLNZ: Ica-atom-technical-architecture-
2008-06.gif]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[JHOVE: Ica-atom-technical-architecture-2008-06.gif|JHOVE: Ica-atom-technical-architecture-
2008-06.gif]]
|
|-
|Ica-atom-technical-architecture-2008-06 (copy).jpg
|Corrupted GIF image file (file extension changed to jpg)
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[DROID: Ica-atom-technical-architecture-2008-06 (copy).jpg]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[NLNZ: Ica-atom-technical-architecture-2008-06 (copy).jpg|NLNZ: Ica-atom-technical-
architecture-2008-06 (copy).jpg]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[JHOVE: Ica-atom-technical-architecture-2008-06 (copy).jpg|JHOVE: Ica-atom-technical-
architecture-2008-06 (copy).jpg]]
|
*DROID correctly identified and warned of possible file extension mismatch
|-
|inkscape_wallpaper___blue_
by_ryanlerch.svg
|SVG image file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[DROID: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_by_ryanlerch.svg|DROID: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_
by_ryanlerch.svg]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_by_ryanlerch.svg|NLNZ: inkscape_wallpaper___
blue_by_ryanlerch.svg]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_by_ryanlerch.svg|JHOVE: inkscape_wallpaper___
blue_by_ryanlerch.svg]]
|
*NLNZ identified as xml file (SVG is an xml extension)
*JHOVE identified as xml file (SVG is an xml extension)
|-
|inkscape_wallpaper___blue_
by_ryanlerch (copy).svg
|Corrupted SVG image file (some xml tags removed)
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_by_ryanlerch (copy).svg|DROID: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_
by_ryanlerch (copy).svg]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_by_ryanlerch (copy).svg|NLNZ: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_
by_ryanlerch (copy).svg]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_by_ryanlerch (copy).svg|JHOVE: inkscape_wallpaper___blue_
by_ryanlerch (copy).svg]]
|
*DROID identified as xml and warned of possible file extension mismatch
*NLNZ identified as xml
*JHOVE identified as ASCII
|-
|Lake Chelan.JPG
|JPEG image file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[DROID: Lake Chelan.JPG]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: Lake Chelan.JPG]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[JHOVE: Lake Chelan.JPG]]
|
|-
|m2a39986.mov
|QuickTime video
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[DROID: m2a39986.mov]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[NLNZ: m2a39986.mov]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''N/A'''
*[[JHOVE: m2a39986.mov]]
|
|-
|manual_excerpt.pdf
|PDF file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[DROID: manual.pdf]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[NLNZ: manual.pdf]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[JHOVE: manual_excerpt.pdf]]
|
|-
|Members_Master2009.xls
|Excel spreadsheet
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: Members_Master2009.xls]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[NLNZ: Members_Master2009.xls]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: Members_Master2009.xls]]
|
*DROID guessed version as either 8 (97-2000) or 8X (2000-2003)
*NLNZ stated version as 4.1+
|-
|Presentation.ppt
|MS PowerPoint presentation with inserted jpeg file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[DROID: Presentation.ppt]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[NLNZ: Presentation.ppt]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: Presentation.ppt]]
|
*DROID did not process inserted jpeg file
*NLNZ identified version as 6.0+. Did not process inserted jpeg file
|-
|Supported standards.doc
|MS Word Document with inserted png file
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: Supported standards.doc]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: Supported standards.doc]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: Supported standards.doc]]
|
*DROID identified as OLE2 Compound Document Format (fmt/111). This format has multiple subtypes, including MS Word 2000-2003. DROID also warned "possible file extension mismatch". Did not process inserted png file.
*NLNZ identified format as Microsoft Word but in version field stated "Microsoft Office Word" instead of giving version number. Did not process inserted png file.
|-
|Supported standards.rtf
|Rich Text Format
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: Supported standards.rtf]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: Supported standards.rtf]]
|
*Identified format? '''NO'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[JHOVE: Supported standards.rtf]]
|
*DROID identified version as either 1.5 or 1.6
*JHOVE identified as ASCII (RTF files are typically encoded in ASCII)
|-
|TechHouse52139.wav
|WAVE audio file
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[DROID: TechHouse52139.wav]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''NO'''
*[[NLNZ: TechHouse52139.wav]]
|
*Identified format? '''YES'''
*Identified version? '''YES'''
*[[JHOVE: TechHouse52139.wav]]
|
*DROID correctly identified as waveform audio but did not identify subtype (pcmwaveformat)
*NLNZ correctly identified as waveform audio but did not identify subtype (pcmwaveformat)
|-

|}

Test File Results - Revision history

Sromkey: Created page with "Main Page > Projects > Vancouver Digital Archives > System Testing > Test File Results == DROID, JHOVE, NLNZ Metadata Extractor == The purpose of these thr..."